Posts Tagged ‘William Garbutt’

Continuing the “British Genoa” theme, here’s an excellent piece from ATP favourite Giancarlo Rinaldi on Giovanni “Johnny” Moscardini. Johnny was a Scottish-born Italian who scored 7 goals in 9 Azzurri appearances and briefly strutted his stuff for the Rossoblu in the 1920’s.

I wish I’d discovered this guy during my own research, but I only discovered this piece earlier today while catching-up on Rinaldi’s excellent blog. I consider myself a Scot first and a Briton second, so while I like Genoa’s English connection (Spensley, Garbutt et al) I absolutely love this tale of one of my countrymen succeeding in calcio. Take a look: it’s a great read.

BBC: The Scotsman who played for Italy

Read Full Post »

Genoa, for me, are a very easy club to identify with because of their English roots. I can’t say that the Rossoblu’s heritage gave me an instant connection to the club but, as a Brit, it caught my attention and got me interested in the club.

It was like bait: at the faintest whiff of a similarity between Genoa and myself I instantly wanted to learn more about the club, their history, and the legacy of their English founders. James Richardson Spensley and William Garbutt aren’t exactly revered in their home country and this is a big shame. I’m willing to bet that calcio would be even more popular in Britain if more of us took the time to research this unique link between our island and Italian football’s genesis.

Spensley and Garbutt both had huge roles to play in shaping Genoa’s early years. Born in London in 1867, Spensley first arrived on the peninsula in early 1896. A doctor, Spensley’s initial duty was to tend to the crews of British coal ships docked in the port city. He joined Genoa’s cricket & athletics club after three months in Italy, and personally opened the club’s footballing section in April 1987.

James Richardson Spensley

Playing as a defender during the club’s first two seasons and a goalkeeper from thereon, Spensley was one of only two players two feature in all of Genoa’s six championship-winning campaigns between 1898 and 1904. He retired a few years after the Grifone’s last title win, and would continue his football career as a coach and referee.

To truly appreciate Spensley’s contribution to Italian football’s development I think it’s important to acknowledge just how big a deal Genoa were back then. Genoa are often believed to be Italy’s first dedicated football club, although there exists evidence suggesting that the first Italian football club was founded in Turin.

The first ever Italian Football Championship took place in 1987. The structure saw several regional groups compete in small round-robin competitions (not unlike today’s Champions League group stage) with the winners advancing to a play-off stage. Genoa bettered three Turinese clubs in this stage of the competition (FBC Torinese, Ginnastica Torino and Internazionale Torino), and eventually beat Internazionale 3-1 to win the competition’s final.

A long period of dominance followed. Think Inter Milan under Jose Mourinho or Roberto Mancini or Milan and Juventus in the 1990’s. Genoa were calcio’s first true powerhouse club, winning 6 out of the first 7 Italian Football Championships, and none of it would’ve been possible without James Richardson Spensley.

Not only did he establish one of calcio’s most significant clubs, but he helped introduce football to the Italian people by forcing through a vote allowing native players to join Genoa C.F.C.’s ranks. Originally Genoa only admitted English players and Italians were hesitant, but the floodgates to over 100 years worth of history in one of the world’s most decorated footballing nations had been opened.

Spensley sadly perished in Mainz, 1910 while on active duty as an army medic during the First World War while compassionately tending to the wounds of a fallen enemy. His name is scarcely mentioned in Britain, but the Genoese will always rightly remember Spensley as one of Italian football’s founding fathers.

William Garbutt

William Garbutt didn’t arrive in Genoa until two years after Spensley’s passing. The Stockport native had had a modest playing career with the likes of Woolwich Arsenal and Blackburn Rovers, but was forced to retire in 1912 (aged 29) as persistent injuries took their toll. In need of a means of supporting his family after his forced retirement, Garbutt moved to Genoa later that year to work as a docker.

He was appointed Genoa’s first ever head coach on the 30th July, but how this came about is unclear. There are two popular theories: some believe that Thomas Coggins (and Irishman who’d been coaching Genoa’s youth team at the time) pushed for his appointment, while others say he was recommended by future World Cup-winning manager Vittorio Pozzo. Either way, Genoa (the most successful club in Italian football to that date) had employed an Englishman with zero managerial experience completely out of the blue.

Garbutt would revolutionise Genoa C.F.C. One of his first acts was to dismantle and re-assemble the Rossoblu’s training methods, and he is noted as one of the first managers to recognise the importance of physical fitness and tactics. To this day Italian football is still known for its tactical sophistication and the superb conditioning of its players, and Garbutt helped set the prototype for both.

As well as his contributions to Italian football’s blueprint, Garbutt conducted the first-ever paid transfer deal on the peninsula and also made Genoa the first Italian club to play outside their native country (they travelled to England to face Garbutt’s former side Reading). He was trendsetter and a true trailblazer. International competition and paid transfers would surely have come along anyway, but it was Garbutt who set the foundations.

Genoa had gone through a rough patch prior to Garbutt’s arrival and hadn’t won an Italian Championship since 1904. The glory of their early days had started to fade, but Garbutt restored some prestige to the club with three Championship wins in 1914-15, 22-23 and 23-24. Genoa haven’t won an Italian championship since.

Garbutt may not have had as big a revolutionary effect on Italian football as Spensley, but his contribution to Genoa was just as immense. Not only did he return the club to its glory days but he did so with dignity and respect. Garbutt helped re-stablise Genoa after the War, and his intelligent approach to management is still being mimicked today.

Post-Genoa, Garbutt would go on to enjoy a long management career with Roma, Napoli, Athletic Bilbao and A.C. Milan. He returned to Genoa on two separate occasions in the thirties and forties, either side of being deported by Mussolini, before eventually returning home and dying peacefully in England, 1964.

It’s perhaps natural that neither of these men are exalted in Britain. Their greatest accomplishments came on foreign shores, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t worthy of reverence. James Richardson Spensley and William Garbutt were helped sculpt calcio into what it is today and I, for one, am very grateful for their contribution.

Further reading:

Les Rosbifs, an excellent site chronicling the fortunes of English footballers abroad, features two excellent articles on Spensley and Garbutt. I’d recommend reading both: the writers are very knowledgeable and the articles are insightful and go into a lot more detail than I ever could.

Paul Edgerton, author of the above article on Garbutt, has released a book on Genoa’s former manager that I will be ordering immediately. I’ve heard nothing but good things about the tome, and I’d recommend you check it out if you have any interest in the man.

Read Full Post »

James Richardson Spensley: one of Genoa's founding fathers.

Genoa Cricket and Football Club are one of the most successful teams in calcio. They’ve won 9 top-tier titles in their history (a total only bettered by Inter Milan, AC Milan and Juventus) with the last of them coming in 1924. In addition to those they’ve won the Coppa Italia once, 6 Serie B titles and a handful of defunct European competitions.

Founded in 1893, Genoa, as a sports club, mainly focused on cricket and athletics (hence the “Cricket” in their name). It wasn’t until 1897 that Englishman James Richardson Spensley opened the football section, making them the third professional football club to form in Italy after Torino and Juventus.

The English connection is what really interests me. Genoa C.F.C. was originally set-up by a group of English to represent their country abroad. Originally the club’s players wore white kits to match those of the English national team, and Italians weren’t allowed to join until the football section opened. Genoa would typically play friendlies against groups of British sailors passing through the port city before the formation of the Italian Championship in 1988.

In 1901 they changed their kits to the red/navy “halves” design that is still used today. Genoa were hugely successful in their early years, and won 6 out of the first 7 Italian Championships (finishing first in 1897-88, 88-89, 99-00, 01-02, 02-03, 03-04 and second in 00-01). In 1903 they created history by becoming the first Italian club to play an international fixture after travelling to France to beat Nice 3-0, but their dominance wasn’t to last.

Things started to slide after their last title win in 1904, and a 1908 FIGC (the Italian FA) ruling forbidding the use of foreign players had a huge impact on their fortunes. Genoa still had a very large contingent of English players at this point, and they withdrew from all FIGC competitions in-protest. They’d eventually return to the league, but the ruling started a rebuilding process that saw the Rossoblu move stadiums and add a number of Swiss players to their squad.

Genoa appointed their first full-time manager in 1912: William Garbutt, another Englishman. Garbutt was with the Rossblu until 1927 and oversaw the club’s recovery. Genoa won 3 championships under Garbutt, but this time period was not without its hardships. Players Luigi Ferraris, Adolfo Gnecco, Carlo Marassi, Alberto Sussone and Claudio Casanova were all killed in active First World War duty, as was founder James Richardson Spensley.

Garbutt’s departure sadly marks the end of Genoa’s golden era. In 1928 the Rossoblu fell foul of Italy’s fascist government, who took umbrage to the club’s English roots and name. They were forced to change their name to Genova 1893 Circolo del Calcio to appease Benito Mussolini. This remained their title until the Axis’ World War II defeat in 1945, when Genoa reverted back to their original name after Mussolini’s death.

The Second World War had a hugely detrimental affect on Italian football as a whole, but Genoa were hit harder than most. Garbutt returned for a spell in-charge but the club’s ability to compete at the highest level had been seriously hampered by the conflict. As city rivals Sampdoria emerged in the late ‘40’s, Genoa went into decline.

A few years of mid-table mediocrity preceded decades of relegation and promotion. Genoa C.F.C. had become a yo-yo club, and even fell as low as Serie C in 1970 as financial difficulties and multiple ownership changes took their toll. The Rossoblu clawed their way back into Serie A in 1973 but continued to flutter between Serie A and Serie B for a few seasons at a time.

Six consecutive Serie A seasons ended with relegation in 1995, and the Rossoblu found themselves stuck in the second-tier for quite some time. Years of mediocrity followed, and Genoa were relegated from Serie B in the 2005-06 season.

Fortunately an upturn was right around the corner. Two consecutive promotions brought Genoa back into Serie A for the 2007-08 season, and they remain there today. A 5th-place finished in 2008-09 saw European competition return to the Stadio Ferraris two seasons ago, but an injury-plagued campaign meant they could only muster a finish of 10th last season.

Genoa have made a reasonable start to the season and currently sit 10th in Serie A after 5 games. Fans will hope for a higher finish than last season, but the sheer volume of players the club turns over every season makes consistency difficult. The Rossoblu seem to revamp their squad every season, and this summer saw 10 new players arrive at the Ferraris and a whopping 26 leave on loans, co-ownership deals and permanent transfers.

I think I’d like to have a closer look at Genoa’s early history later this week. There’s a lot of interesting stuff in there, and I’m particularly intrigued by the English connection and the effect that the two World Wars had on the Rossoblu. Aside from that, I’d like to take a look at their current squad and assess Genoa’s chances of possibly returning to their former glory.

Next up: more on Garbutt, Spensley and Genoa’s English roots.




Read Full Post »